You Actually Share Your Brain With a Silent Stranger

In progressCGP Greyvideo2016-05-31read planted cognitive sciencephilosophy of mind

Synopsis — AI-drafted from Dan's notes

A five-minute explainer from CGP Grey on split-brain patients, first released as “You Are Two”. Each hemisphere sees and steers the opposite half of the body, and the two talk through a bundle of nerves, the corpus callosum, which surgeons once cut to treat severe epilepsy. Afterwards patients seemed unchanged, except that one hand sometimes disagreed with the other.

The experiments separate the halves. Speech sits in the left hemisphere (in most people), so show a word only to the right and the patient says they saw nothing, while the left hand, run by the right hemisphere, picks the matching object out of a pile. Ask why they are holding it, and the speaking half invents a plausible, wrong reason. Grey’s point is that this is not lying: making up reasons for what we did is something the talking brain does in healthy people all the time, and he notes, in passing, what that might mean for free will. The right hemisphere, mute, still hears, understands and answers, and is the stronger at faces.

Then he labels his speculation as speculation: maybe surgery doesn’t create a second mind but reveals one that was always there, a partner that went quiet once speech took over. Either way, he argues, the patients show that something in the skull besides the speaker can hear and respond. It closes with a hand-off to Kurzgesagt’s companion video on the many cells that make one self.

Connections