The AI data center overbuild is starting to worry people | Paris Marx
Dan PetersonSynopsis — AI-drafted from Dan's notes
Isaac Pound sits down in person with Paris Marx, whose book Hyperscale: The Ambition and Excess of Big Tech’s Data Empires came out on 20 October. The book covers what data centres demand of the places they land (power, water, emissions, the chip supply chain), the economic and ideological case behind them, and whether the same benefits could come from far less computation. Asked who AI is being built for, Marx names the founders chasing AGI, then the cloud giants who sell the compute, the fossil-fuel industry powering it, and the military, pointing to reporting that Claude was used in US strikes on Iran.
Isaac brings a Web Summit survey of about 1,500 people in tech, in which 59 per cent said AI had added to their workload. Marx is not surprised: tools pushed into places they don’t fit, output that has to be checked, and users who feel faster than they are. He cites Accenture, which now funds $29 a month of Claude per employee centrally and charges heavier use to project budgets. His bigger worry is deskilling: programmers who no longer write code, junior lawyers never trained because a chatbot does the groundwork, students outsourcing learning. He adds dependence on American services, with Europe building alternatives that the UK and Canada mostly aren’t.
His forecast is a reassessment: companies drifting from expensive frontier models to cheaper, targeted open-weight ones, and a data-centre buildout the market already doubts. Isaac cites an ABC/Post/Ipsos poll in which 57 per cent of Americans call AI bad for society. Marx’s view is that the danger is not extinction but emissions and present harms, and that the labs use the extinction story to crowd those out. His example is Ontario’s auditor general, whose tests on simulated doctor-patient recordings found nine of twenty approved AI scribes inventing details and twelve recording the wrong drug. What gives him hope is local opposition to data centres, from across the political spectrum.
Connections
Links
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PzTR8xrCVkU
- https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/797020/hyperscale-by-paris-marx/
- https://thenextweb.com/news/ai-workload-web-summit-state-of-the-industry-survey
- https://abcnews.com/Politics/americans-ai-bad-society-oppose-data-centers-abcpostipsos/story?id=137414085
- https://globalnews.ca/news/11844349/ontario-auditor-general-ai-usage/