Who is the NHL's Most Overrated Player?

In progressSpreadsheet Sports Hockeyvideo2026-10-29read planted hockeymath

Synopsis — AI-drafted from Dan's notes

Spreadsheet Sports turns the impact model from his “most underrated” video around. Each of 618 skaters gets two ranks: an impact rank from the data, and an expert rank averaged across the preseason lists from ESPN, The Hockey News, TSN and NHL Network. Overrated means the experts rank a player far above the data, and he looks only at their top 20. Last season counts double the one before, players need 35 games, goalies are left out, and he is careful to say overrated does not mean bad.

The leader changes with each version. On points per game alone it is Auston Matthews, but his 2025-26 was cut short by a knee injury (53 points in 60 games), and adding expected goals and game score puts him back near the experts’ rank. Mitch Marner then leads, because he creates so few chances for himself. Adding on-ice impact at five-on-five, the team’s chances with a player on the ice against with him on the bench, brings up Sidney Crosby, and adding defence drops Crosby to 156th. He checks two excuses: whether a player is a passenger on a star’s line (Crosby’s numbers hold up away from Bryan Rust), and whether tough matchups drag him down. From the shift charts, Crosby does face hard competition but also starts more shifts in the offensive zone than most forwards, and the two roughly cancel.

The top three: Mikko Rantanen, the one who fails the passenger test, losing ground without Wyatt Johnston and paid $12 million a year by Dallas; Marner, now in Vegas, with 80 points but 56 of them assists; and Crosby, 74 points in 68 games at 38, with Pittsburgh roughly breaking even at five-on-five when he is out there. He is at pains to honour Crosby’s record and leadership, which no model measures, and concludes that the experts are ranking the legend while the data ranks the player he is now.

Connections