I Built a Model to Find the Unluckiest NHL Player Ever
Dan PetersonSynopsis — AI-drafted from Dan's notes
Spreadsheet Sports sets out to find not the best player without a Cup but the unluckiest career. He pulls every NHL season since 1926, keeps the 305 best finished careers by point shares plus every Hall of Famer, and builds the definition of bad luck up in versions. Great and Cupless puts Roberto Luongo first. Version two asks how many Cups each player’s teams should have won, giving each team a share of each year’s Cup from its regular season; he backtests it a season at a time and reports that it is well calibrated (teams given about 12% won 11.7% of the time). That moves Joe Thornton up. Version three counts the share of a prime (ages 22 to 31) lost to injury, which briefly puts Cam Neely on top.
Version four counts seasons ended by the eventual champion, weighted for dynasties and lost Finals, and one player laps the field. Later versions add series lost in a deciding game, goals lost to cold shooting and goaltending, weak teammates, runner-up award finishes, and being traded away by a team that then won: Detroit sent Dino Ciccarelli to Tampa Bay in 1996 and won the next two Cups, and the Islanders traded Glenn “Chico” Resch in March 1981 and won the next three. Admitting he chose the weights, he then runs 10,000 versions with random weights, pools and team ratings, sometimes dropping a factor. The same player finishes first in 79.5% of them and top five in 98.5%.
It is Brad Park, the Hall of Fame defenceman for the Rangers and Bruins. He finished second for the Norris Trophy six times, four behind Bobby Orr and two behind Denis Potvin, and lost three Finals: to Orr’s Bruins in 1972 and to Montreal in 1977 and 1978. He was on the 1979 Bruins whose too-many-men penalty let Montreal tie Game 7 and win in overtime. Simulated 10,000 times, Park’s career wins at least one Cup 86% of the time. The final five, from fifth, are Resch, John Vanbiesbrouck, Ciccarelli, Ray Bourque and Park, and Jean Ratelle, traded to Boston in the same 1975 deal as Park, keeps turning up near the top for the same reasons.